I agree completely. Also if people start off by immediately being condescending\agressive it's quickly going to dissolve into a cesspool. If we all could be professional about this matter then it could work but without admins I wouldn't count on it.
Also scammers could use such a thread as well. We already know they make multiple accounts so they could very well post in this type of thread, making stuff up about other users just to confuse everybody and try to distract from real accusations. Unfortunately there are many ways such a thread could be abused. It's easy to just say "someone told me this person is bad trust me" and escalate things from there.
Last edited: Feb 26, 2018