Finally finished playing this with my brother! What a weird episode. It was seriously confusing in parts. As for the ending, I can see why people don't like it but I thought it was really the only choice that could be had at the end. We tried the "sacrifice Arcadia Bay" ending first - holy shit. Nope. So many dead people. We both agreed the "sacrifice Chloe" ending was also really sad, but the better one because it fit and there wasn't an entire dead town. Tbh, the part where you can tell David that Chloe is dead is like one hundred times sadder than ANYTHING else in the game. Jesus. We felt horrible and immediately rewound. XD Also, Mr. Jefferson's voice actor is freaking amazing for being able to have that kind of emotional range.